Caster Semenya Hemaphrodite Essay - Paper Example Caster Semenya Hemaphrodite Essay In our society today we only have two categories male and female then what about the in-betweens hermaphrodites and pseudo-hermaphrodites which categories do they fit in - Caster Semenya Hemaphrodite Essay introduction. Hermaphrodites have both the male and female organs due to them having both the xx and xy chromosomes but in our society you can only be one. In most recent events the sex of a female South African athlete Caster Semenya has been in question because a gender test revealed that Caster is both man and women and the medal that she won might be stripped away due to these results. Caster Semenya was born in South Africa and has been running ever since she was young, even at a young age Caster has been always teased as a tomboy because she liked playing sports with boys and had a boyish look but that never stopped her from running and playing with them.
The outcome shocked and humiliated the athlete, who had never doubted her status as a woman.
Patino was encouraged to drop out of competition but she defended herself to critics, eventually winning back the ability to compete as a female athlete.
Patino is not the only major athlete to face accusations of this nature. Like Patino, Semenya fought against her critics, enduring intense public scrutiny during an embarrassing investigation.
The sex verification investigation eventually permitted Semenya to continue to compete in the Olympics as a woman, where she earned a silver medal. These two cases illustrate the difficulties associated with sex verification within competitive athletic environments.
Those concerned with sex verification argue that their effort is required to ensure a fair playing field. However, sex verification can be a humiliating process for the athletes who, after living as women all their lives, must endure the scrutiny and judgment of others.
Sex verification is problematic because no easy answer exists. Many different factors are relevant to the determination of the sex of a human being. The first factor to consider is biology. If a person has two X chromosomes, that person is female while the person with an X and a Y chromosome is male.
However, the biological determination of sex is not so simple due to activity of the SRY gene. This gene is typically found on a Y gene and triggers the fetus to develop as a male.
However, the gene can appear on an X gene or not function as expected as a Y, resulting in unexpected sexual development. Therefore, while the X and Y chromosomes may provide some guidance toward developing a clear biological determination of sex, they are not sufficient to end the controversy.
Psychological factors such as self-perception are also relevant. Individuals see themselves in a certain way. They will then choose to present themselves to society in a way consistent with how they view themselves.
Race is an analogous case.
Scientists once believed race to have a biological component but today recognize that race is a social construction. Individuals may choose to identify as a particular race or as biracial, depending upon their personal preferences and circumstances.
Therefore, with no clear bright line offered by biology, sex arises more as a social construction resulting from the negotiation of different interactions between people.
Both Maria Patino and Caster Semenya consider themselves to be women. Like most people, they were likely told their sex initially by their parents. They were then labeled as females by others as they matured. Comfortable with their status as women, they fought to maintain their identities as women in a public battle experienced by relatively few.
In the past, men and women were identified by their external genitalia. However, some people have both sets of genitalia, some have neither.
The inability of external genitalia to offer a clear answer on how to determine sex has led to the effort to develop a new method of determining sex that can help to explain the apparent aberrations from the dichotomy.
For this reason, health texts acknowledge multiple sexes within a continuum, rather than the duality of just male or female. However, regardless of the exact test selected to formally determine sex, individuals will continue to decide for themselves whether to live as women or as men.Caster Semenya: Hermaphrodite Essay - Caster Semenya is a black athlete track star from South Africa and is a gold medal winner for the meters at the World Championships with the fastest time of the year finishing the race with time and after this event many have questioned her gender due to her masculine physique and built.
Caster Semenya Controversy Essay The Controversy over Caster Semenya The article titled “ Caster Semenya An the IOC’s Olympics Gender Bender” by Jesse Ellison reviews the controversy over Caster Semenya, the now year-old intersexed athlete, and whether or not she should be allowed to compete as a female in international competition.
Caster Semenya Hemaphrodite Essay In our society today we only have two categories male and female then what about the in-betweens hermaphrodites and pseudo-hermaphrodites which categories do they fit in - Caster Semenya Hemaphrodite Essay introduction.
Mokgadi Caster Semenya OIB (born 7 January ) is a South African middle-distance runner and Olympic gold medalist.
The curious case of Caster Semenya: intersexed athletes and competitive advantage Published on 18/08/ 16/11/ by Society for Endocrinology Following the recent media coverage of Caster Semenya competing at the Rio Olympics , we have republished an abridged version of Harriet Nerva’s essay on disorders of sexual development, which. The curious case of Caster Semenya: intersexed athletes and competitive advantage Published on 18/08/ 16/11/ by Society for Endocrinology Following the recent media coverage of Caster Semenya competing at the Rio Olympics , we have republished an abridged version of Harriet Nerva’s essay on disorders of sexual development, which won the Society for Endocrinology . Caster Semenya, an year-old from South Africa, won the world championships in the meters last week in Berlin. Her time of was the fifth fastest in world history. Even more impressive is her rags-to-riches story: up until recently, she was an unknown runner from .
Semenya won gold in the women's metres at the World Championships with a time of and at the World Championships in her new personal best, Essay. Sports. NY Times. In today's society we assume that there are only two categories in sex, they are, male and female. The sex of a person is determined by the X and Y chromosomes and this is something that has been taught to us right from our school days.
If two XX chromosomes come together then the sex of th. Caster’s gender test came out that she was a hermaphrodite but does that really matter.
Caster was raise by both of her parents as a girl and her village accepted her as a girl so why should she be subjected to this humiliation by the world’s standards of how a girl should look like and be stripped of her medal that she earned through her.